I saw Catch Me if you Can on Thursday, June 16th at the Neil Simon Theatre. I sat in the front-row left mezzanine, which were absolutely amazing seats. I could see everything happening onstage. The theatre is timeless and beautiful, however, it’s very cramped and barely any legroom (and I was front row.)
The story is based of the movie blockbuster – Catch Me if you Can - starring Leonardo DiCaprio and Tom Hanks. It’s the real-life story of Frank Abagnale Jr. Frank was a con-artist who stole millions of dollars in bad checks. Carl Hanratty is a FBI agent who devotes his life to catch Frank. Soon enough, he figures out that he’s a kid (Frank was 16 when he ran away from home) and sympathizes for him. Other topics include Frank’s parents getting a divorce and Frank’s love interest in the story – Brenda. Unlike the movie, the musical really goes into the relationships of all the characters in more depth. I noticed a lot of the same scenes, but I still think the musical did a good job of keeping it’s originality while keeping the movie in mind.
The actors were perfectly casted in their roles. Aaron Tveit is such a strong singer, dancer, and actor. He carried the whole show on his back – and did a fantastic job. I say this without being a complete fangirl: He was robbed for a Tony nomination. He should’ve definitely been nominated – especially if the show was nominated for Best Musical. He had amazing chemistry with every actor onstage and he had a presence that was perfect for the role. He played it innocently, but still very suave. I really hope Aaron has a long career ahead of him because he’s truly extraordinary.
Norbert Leo Butz definitely deserved his Tony. He was the “heart” of the show – which I think is essential for most shows. His song was an absolute show-stopper. He can dance like so incredibly, yet still carry the song with his voice. Norbert and Aaron have a very unique chemistry – something you don’t find onstage too often. They seemed so comfortable onstage together, like they were born to one day work together.
Kerry Butler fit her role perfectly. With all the dazzling showgirls, it was refreshing to watch Kerry – so ordinary, but unique in her special ways. She clearly defines the “Big things come in small packages” quote. The woman is so small, but her voice fills the room. I do think she was underused. I wish she could’ve had more stage time, although I soaked up every minute she was onstage. The rest of the cast supported the principals wonderfully.
The set was one of my favorite aspects. I loved having the orchestra onstage. I’ve seen two shows like that – Next to Normal and Catch Me if you Can - and I think I prefer it more. Watching the musicians is a very special dynamic – one that I hope shows continue with. In CMIYC, either the set would be raised from below the stage or the actors would simply push pieces on. I’m loving simplicity right now. Though Catch Me wasn’t totally simplistic, with the band’s part of the stage being very fancy, it had a great balance. Being a Libra (scales/balance), I think balance is important. The show was probably more over-the-top than simplistic, but it still was perfect, in my opinion.
Overall, the show was absolutely spectacular. Like a lot of people have said, it’s one of the best musicals in years. So classic and timeless, yet modern and unique. I’m hoping (maybe the announcement has been made) that it’ll go on tour. If you have the opportunity to see it – GO. That’s all I can say. It’s wonderfully written and the music is fabulous. Marc and Scott did yet another fantastic job. I think that it’ll be interesting to see how big the show gets. Hairspray is a huge hit for community theatres, and I wonder if Catch Me will be the next hit. I hope it goes far though because it’s terrific.
Should it have gotten more Tony nominations? Yes! A lot more.
Should it have won Best Musical? No. Book of Mormon was completely worthy of that title. However, if Mormon came out another season, I think it would’ve had a good chance.
I probably left out a few parts for a substantial Broadway review, but if you have any direct comments about anything – feel free to comment below!!
- Maya
P.S. I’ll post all of my stagedoor and show pictures when I have the opportunity!